0days in a row Director's Cut
Bollywood

Hirani and Joshi defend PK’s Lord Shiva scene 12 years later

Rajkumar Hirani and Abhijat Joshi say the controversial PK chase involved a stage actor, not Lord Shiva, and was written with pure intentions.

PK's Lord Shiva scene was written with pure intent

Rajkumar Hirani and Abhijat Joshi have revisited one of PK’s most debated scenes, more than a decade after Aamir Khan’s alien landed in cinemas and began questioning every belief in sight.

In a conversation with Komal Nahta, the director-writer duo returned to the 2014 sequence in which PK spots a stage artiste dressed as Lord Shiva, mistakes him for the real deity and ends up chasing him. A section of the audience had found the moment in bad taste when the film released.

Hirani, however, said there was no fear while writing it: “We didn’t at all.”

The Shiva chase, as the writers see it

Joshi said the person in question is not Lord Shiva at all. He is an actor in a stage play who is about to perform the role of Lord Shiva. PK, an alien who does not know the concept of God, simply assumes the man is the real deity.

“There was no intention to make fun,” Hirani said. “We were making bigger points actually in the film.” He added that issues can happen with anything.

Why an alien, and why it matters

Joshi explained that the alien protagonist was not a gimmick. It let the film raise questions about belief with childlike innocence rather than arrogance. Hirani was clear that PK could not be condescending, because people hold real beliefs and the film was questioning those beliefs.

Hirani said that innocence is what makes the questioning work. PK is not saying “this is wrong”; he is asking why, and the audience starts asking too.

  • The chase: A case of mistaken identity inside a stage play, not a direct comment on Lord Shiva.
  • The device: An alien’s innocence lets the film question belief without mockery.
  • The reaction: The writers were shocked, and Joshi remains frustrated that a non-issue became an issue.

The frustration that remains

Joshi admitted the backlash still stings: “jo baat hai hi nahin, usko issue banaya gaya.” He said the team respects people’s sentiments and wrote the film with pure intentions.

The exchange captures how a scene can have two lives—the one on the page and the one in public memory. For fans who follow the stars as closely as the films, it also shows how the makers of a blockbuster still speak about intent years after the controversy faded.

As film conversations continue to move online, PK remains a useful case study: an innocent question can still become a flashpoint when viewers see a deity where the writers saw a stage actor.

Source: bollywoodHungama.com

The room talks

0 comments

Say it on the record

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Keep scrolling — the next scoop pulls up