Hirani and Joshi: Biopics need 70-80% accuracy, not perfect logic
Rajkumar Hirani and Abhijat Joshi talk logic in cinema, the 3 Idiots same-day coincidence fans miss, and why biopics need only 70-80% accuracy.

Mumbai: Rajkumar Hirani and writer Abhijat Joshi have built their films on a simple wager: audiences will accept a bending of calendar logic if the emotional payoff is strong enough. In a conversation with trade journalist Komal Nahta, they went back to 3 Idiots and pointed to a stretch that would fail a screenwriting class.
A single day, three huge turns
Joshi broke down the sequence. News about Rancho’s whereabouts arrives, Shamaldas Chanchad dies, and Pia is set to be married—all on the same day. “It’ll not pass any screenwriting class,” Joshi said, as quoted by Bollywood Hungama, because the coincidences are enormous. Yet, he noted, people have seen 3 Idiots countless times and rarely think about it.
Hirani’s framing is that logic matters hugely in certain kinds of cinema, but filmmakers can take cinematic liberty—provided the audience does not catch them. The moment a viewer feels “yaar, aisa ho nahin sakta”, he said, the connection snaps.
What the 3 Idiots example really explains
This is dramatic compression at work. Filmmakers collapse time so conflicts that may have unfolded days or weeks apart land together, which heightens the emotion. The gamble works only when characters’ motivations are clear and the payoff feels earned. In 3 Idiots, the same day pushes Rancho’s mystery, a death and a wedding into one urgent mission.
Hirani and Joshi are not saying logic is irrelevant. They are drawing a line between films that can be absurd—like slapstick—and films that ask the audience to invest in believable stakes.
- Emotion before chronology: a story can compress time if the character beats stay true.
- Biopics need stricter fidelity: Joshi says a real-life story should be 70-80% accurate.
- Core values are non-negotiable: you can shuffle dates, but not the basic facts of who did what.
Biopics: accuracy with a heart
When the subject moved to real-life stories, Joshi argued that while no film is 100% accurate, the essence must be truthful. He joked that a filmmaker cannot pretend the British were invited to build Lutyens’ Delhi and left after 150 years when the work was done—if someone does that, “my blood boils.” Hirani pointed to Gandhi as an example of likely timeline changes, made so the drama does not become boring.
That line—“you can take cinematic liberty, provided you don’t get caught”—explains a lot of mainstream Hindi cinema. It is why an interval twist can feel thrilling rather than implausible: the maker has done the work to keep the audience inside the story. The next time you rewatch 3 Idiots, the same-day coincidence may be visible, but the film still works because it spends its emotional capital well.
For viewers, the takeaway is simple: watch what is compressed and ask why. A good coincidence is a shortcut to feeling; a bad one is a shortcut out of the story. In biopics, the test is whether values and truth survive the adaptation.
Source: Bollywood Hungama
The room talks
0 comments